The Florida Bar

Standing Committees
Judicial Administration & Evaluation

The Judicial Administration and Evaluation Committee has the responsibility of accepting specific assignments from the Board of Governors in areas regarding the judiciary. The committee prior to each legislative session reviews all legislation prefiled pertinent to the judiciary and makes recommendations either to the Board of Governors or the Legislation Committee.

The committee is concerned with obtaining and then retaining qualified judicial officers. Not only are the selection and retention processes monitored, but consideration is also given to making judicial offices more attractive to qualified attorneys.

The Judicial Administration and Evaluation Committee also assists the Florida Supreme Court in the Judicial feedback program. Trial and appellate court feedback forms and an example of how the confidential envelope should look are available in PDF format . Attorneys may also use online feedback forms.

The goal of the feedback program is to provide a confidential means by which attorney members of The Florida Bar can communicate with appellate or trial court judges concerning their perceived specific strengths and weaknesses. Providing judges with confidential feedback, assists them with self-assessment and self-improvement. The voluntary, confidential feedback program for trial and appellate court judges began January 1, 1998.

Feedback may be provided in two ways; by filling out a form and mailing it to The Florida Bar or by completing feedback forms online at

By mail:
On the trial court level, the court includes a Judicial Feedback Form and an envelope addressed to the judge in care of The Florida Bar when the court mails the Final Order ending the case to counsel of record. On the appellate court level, the clerk transmits the Judicial Feedback Form and associated instructions to all counsel of record who participated in the appeal at the time the appellate opinion is sent. Trial and appellate court feedback forms and an example of how the confidential envelope should look are available in PDF format .

There are separate forms for trial court judges and appellate court judges. Judges and attorneys can access the feedback form by going to and following the prompts. Security is assured. To participate you need to have your Bar number and your Bar password. You can click on a prompt that will assist you in obtaining your Bar password.

All feedback is confidential pursuant to Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2.051(c)(4). The judge may communicate the substance of the feedback to the chief judge or to another judge for the purpose of peer input, but otherwise the feedback may not be disclosed to any other person.

The committee hopes that this program will provide judges with useful and accurate substantive input from attorneys practicing before them, and it requests the support of all judges and attorneys in ensuring its success. The committee continues its work in evaluating and fine turning these programs and exploring other means.

The committee also has a model judicial evaluation procedure to be used in the state which will include methods of evaluation broader than performance polls. It is the function of the committee to continually improve judicial performance.

Another function of the committee is to oversee the Merit Retention Poll Guidelines for District Court of Appeal Judges and Supreme Court Justices (Appellate Courts) retention program which is held every other year.

Judicial Candidate Self-Disclosure Statements

Staff Contact    Doris Maffei
Kelly Ann O'Keefe Chair Tallahassee  2016
Lisa Davidson Vice Chair Viera  2017
Ross Mathew Goodman Vice Chair Pensacola  2016
Lansing Charles Scriven Board Liaison Tampa  2015
Joseph M Abdallah Delray Beach  2016
Jeffrey Alan Albinson Tampa  2017
Aramis Donell Ayala Orlando  2016
Jo Ann Barone West Palm Beach  2015
Thomas Michael Bates West Palm Beach  2016
Pam Elaine Booker Port St Lucie  2016
Melina Buncome Jacksonville  2016
Cosme Caballero Miami  2017
Harry Lee Coe, IV Tampa  2017
Alexis Marie Connell Tampa  2016
Gabrielle Lyn D'Alemberte Miami  2017
Jessica Garcia Davie  2015
Merrick Lawrence Gross Miami  2016
John Mark Howe West Palm Beach  2016
Jonathan Blake Hunter Tallahassee  2017
Michael Jay Karpinski Bentonville  2015
Dora Faye Kaufman Miami  2015
Percy A King Jacksonville  2017
Timothy Andrew Kolaya Miami  2016
Alicia Lynette Latimore Orlando  2016
Keith Patrick Ligori Tampa  2017
Paul Jeffrey Martin Tallahassee  2017
Joseph Daniel Pickles Jacksonville  2016
Israel Umberto Reyes Coral Gables  2016
Jane A Rose Tampa  2016
Jesse Preston Silvernail Satellite Beach  2015
Jennifer Ashley Smith Orlando  2017
Victor Ramsey Smith Winter Haven  2017
Barry Joel Stone Boynton Beach  2015
Alberto F Tellechea-Hermida Orlando  2015
Andrew Broin Thomson Boca Raton  2016
Michael John Trentalange Tampa  2016
Jeannine Smith Williams Saint Petersburg  2017

[Revised: 7-1-2014]